On December 15th, 1890, Sitting Bull, the famed Lakota leader and holy man known in his own language as Tatanka Iyotake, was killed during an attempted arrest by Indian police at the Standing Rock Reservation. His death marked the loss of one of the most influential Indigenous leaders of the 19th century and became a pivotal moment in a chain of events that culminated days later in the Wounded Knee Massacre.
Yet to understand Sitting Bull only by the manner of his death is to misunderstand him entirely. He was not merely a symbol of resistance, nor simply a casualty of a violent era; he was a spiritual leader, a strategist, a statesman, and a man deeply rooted in the traditions and responsibilities of his people.
Sitting Bull was born around 1831 among the Hunkpapa Lakota, part of the larger Sioux Nation. From an early age, he distinguished himself through courage, composure, and spiritual seriousness rather than boastfulness. Lakota tradition placed high value on humility, vision, and responsibility to the community, and Sitting Bull grew into those ideals rather than chasing personal glory. He earned his name after demonstrating bravery in battle as a young man, but his reputation was built over decades, not moments.
Unlike many leaders remembered primarily for warfare, Sitting Bull was first and foremost a holy man. He was a keeper of sacred ceremonies and a man believed to possess spiritual insight, someone whose visions carried weight because they were understood to come with responsibility. In Lakota society, spiritual authority was not symbolic; it shaped decisions about survival, movement, diplomacy, and resistance.
Sitting Bull rose to prominence during a period when the Lakota world was under increasing pressure from U.S. expansion, broken treaties, and military encroachment. He consistently opposed treaties that ceded Lakota land without the full consent of the people, particularly those involving the Black Hills, which the Lakota regarded as sacred. His refusal to sign away land was not obstinance but adherence to a worldview in which land was not a commodity to be sold, but a trust held for future generations.
One of Sitting Bull’s most significant historical roles came in the years leading up to the Battle of the Little Bighorn in 1876. Though he was not a battlefield commander in the modern sense, Sitting Bull’s leadership was crucial in uniting bands of Lakota and Cheyenne at a time when division could have meant annihilation. During a Sun Dance ceremony prior to the battle, he reportedly experienced a vision of soldiers falling into the Lakota camp like grasshoppers, a vision interpreted as a sign of victory.
The subsequent defeat of Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer and the 7th Cavalry became one of the most famous Indigenous victories in North American history. While others led the fighting, Sitting Bull’s influence as a unifying figure and spiritual anchor was widely acknowledged. Importantly, he did not treat the victory as a triumph to exploit, but as a temporary reprieve in a much larger struggle.
After years of resistance, Sitting Bull led his followers into exile in Canada to avoid forced reservation life. Even there, he attempted to maintain peace and dignity, refusing to become a pawn in foreign politics. When food shortages and hardship made return unavoidable, he eventually surrendered, not as a defeated man, but as a leader seeking survival for his people under impossible conditions.
In later years, Sitting Bull became an international figure, even traveling briefly with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show. He used the opportunity not to glorify violence, but to speak openly about Indigenous suffering and injustice, often donating his earnings to the poor. Despite being portrayed by some as dangerous or unpredictable, contemporaries noted his calm demeanor and sharp intellect.
By 1890, fear rather than evidence drove federal authorities’ actions. The Ghost Dance movement, a spiritual revival promising renewal and the return of balance, spread rapidly among Indigenous communities devastated by loss, starvation, and confinement. Though Sitting Bull’s direct involvement was limited, authorities feared his influence alone could lend the movement legitimacy. That fear led to the decision to arrest him.
The attempt ended in chaos. During the confrontation, shots were fired, and Sitting Bull was killed along with several others. His death sent shockwaves through Indigenous communities and intensified tensions across the region. Within days, those tensions would erupt at Wounded Knee, where U.S. troops killed hundreds of Lakota men, women, and children.
Sitting Bull’s death was not the end of resistance, but it symbolized the closing of an era. He represented a generation of Indigenous leaders who fought not for conquest, but for the right to exist according to their own laws, beliefs, and responsibilities.
Today, Sitting Bull is remembered not simply as a warrior, but as a man who refused to surrender his conscience. He stood against injustice without abandoning dignity, led without seeking domination, and held fast to spiritual truth in a world determined to erase it. His legacy endures because it speaks not only to Lakota history, but to universal questions of courage, faith, and moral conviction.
Appalachian Post 
Leave a comment